Whispers in the Vault: Why Gold Stocks Remain the Market’s Forgotten Giants

In the hushed stillness of an underground vault, gold glints under soft lamplight: flawless, immovable, eternal. Stacked in bricks, bars, and bullion, it represents civilization’s oldest safe haven, its most enduring measure of value. Right now, that vault, the physical stockpile of above-ground gold, hovers near a staggering $24 trillion.

But step outside, into the daylight of financial markets, and the contrast is jarring. The companies that toil to bring that gold to light - from the drills at Nevada’s massive pits to the shafts of South Africa - are collectively dwarfed in value. Publicly traded gold miners combined are worth less than $1 trillion, a sliver compared to the gleaming mountain of bullion already above ground.

It’s a paradox whispered among analysts: the store of value is massive, but the engines that unearth it remain overlooked, still arguably underpriced, and by most measures under-owned.

‍

The Disparity: Gold Demand Soars, Yet Miners Lag

The latest data paints the picture in sharp relief. In Q2 2025, global gold demand rose 3% year-on-year to 1,249 tonnes. In dollar terms, however, demand surged an astonishing 45%, reaching an all-time record of US $132 billion. Investors piled into ETFs and physical coins, driving flows not seen since the pandemic panic years.

Yet mine production barely inched forward. It grew just 1%, reaching 909 tonnes, a sluggish climb against the backdrop of booming demand. Jewelry consumption, long a driver of gold markets, buckled under high spot prices. But investment appetite - from sovereign funds to retail buyers - more than made up the gap.

The numbers tell a clear story: demand is growing, value is exploding, but supply is stuck in slow gear. Despite gold soaring in value, production has barely increased.

The Supply Squeeze: Why Gold Production Can’t Keep Up

Dig deeper, and the miners’ struggle becomes clear. Among the GDX 25 - the world’s largest gold miners - production actually fell 9.6% in Q2, marking their worst quarterly decline in nearly 40 years. Even adjusted, the sector showed only the faintest uptick.

Costs, meanwhile, are surging. Average cash costs among top producers jumped 14.5% year-over-year to $1,186 per ounce in 2024. Labor shortages, stricter environmental permitting, declining ore grades, and rising energy prices all conspire to make new gold harder - and more expensive - to bring online. All-in sustaining costs continue to march higher with many of the largest companies seeing double digit increases in recent quarters.

EY’s annual mining risk report underscored it plainly: building a new gold mine is harder now than at any point in modern history. Projects face multi-year permitting delays, regulatory red tape, rising construction costs, and fierce local opposition. Even when miners want to expand, the ground beneath them fights back with lower grades and higher strip ratios.

In other words: no matter how high the gold price runs, mine supply is not elastic. The “easy ounces” have already been dug.

‍

Revelation: The Market’s Blind Spot

This is where the revelation strikes. Investors are rewarding the vault, but ignoring the keyholders. Gold ETFs are swelling; sovereign banks from Beijing to Ankara are stockpiling bullion; retail buyers queue for coins. Yet the miners—the literal producers of the world’s most coveted asset—are priced as though they barely matter.

Americans in particular reflect this neglect. Surveys of household portfolios show minuscule allocation to gold equities, often well under 1% of total assets. Even institutional investors, who speak often about diversification, typically carry token exposure to miners compared to tech or financials.

The result? Gold miners remain a forgotten giant, a sector worth less than the annual U.S. budget deficit, despite sitting atop billions of ounces of reserves with in-situ value that, on paper, runs into the tens of trillions.

‍

A Historical Echo: When Miners Outrun Gold

History whispers a warning here. In past cycles, miners have often lagged bullion at first, only to surge later in explosive bursts of outperformance. In the late 1970s, as gold sprinted to $850 an ounce, gold equities delivered returns that multiplied bullion’s gains. A similar story played out in the early 2000s bull market, when Newmont and Barrick shares tripled while gold itself merely doubled.

The pattern is consistent: gold leads, miners lag, and then, once the investing public at large join the party, the miners sprint ahead.

Why? Because miners are leveraged plays on gold. Their revenues expand faster than costs when prices rise, magnifying profits. That leverage cuts both ways, of course, which is why many investors shy away. But in an era where production growth is constrained, the survivors may command even greater scarcity value.

‍

The Mountain: Picture it as a climb

Base Camp: Gold demand hits records, ETF inflows accelerate, and central banks hoard bullion.

The Ascent: As the bull market matures, investors move down the value chain, from gold-backed ETFs to large miners, medium producers and finally junior explorers.

The Summit: The price of gold rises faster than the cost to mine it and profits along with valuations soar as mainstreet piles into the limited number of publicly traded gold miners.

The climb is fraught with tension. Often, especially early on, investors keep pouring into bullion, ignoring the companies that provide it. Regulators keep tightening their grip, slowing expansion. Costs keep rising, squeezing margins.

And yet - the summit reveals a strange truth: scarcity itself is becoming the miners’ hidden asset. The fewer new projects that break ground, the more valuable existing producers’ reserves become.

‍

Undervalued by Design?

Some argue miners are undervalued by design. After all, they carry operational risks, strikes, floods, coups, debt burdens, that bullion does not. Investors seeking “pure” gold exposure can buy ETFs and avoid the headaches.

But in doing so, the market discards the embedded value in reserves and resources. It’s as though the world treasures the golden apple, but forgets the tree.

Measured collectively, gold miners hold billions of ounces in proven reserves. Even at conservative prices, the in-situ value runs into the tens of trillions of dollars. Yet the entire sector is priced at less than Apple, a single U.S. tech stock.

That is the disconnect - an undervaluation born not of scarcity of value, but of scarcity of attention. Finally, after more than a decade in the shadows, gold and gold miners are having their moment.

‍

The Silent Allocation

For most American investors, gold equities are a footnote. U.S. household allocation to gold stocks is vanishingly small, overshadowed by tech, real estate, and bonds. Even professional asset managers rarely dedicate more than a token slice of portfolios.

The irony is stark: in a world of record debt, fiscal uncertainty, and persistent inflation, the miners who produce real, tangible value remain nearly invisible in the average portfolio.

This is not a prescription, nor advice - merely an observation of neglect. A market’s blind spot.

‍

Why Gold Stocks Remain the Undervalued Pulse of the Market

The vault glows with $24 trillion worth of metal. Demand is surging; investors are clamoring; central banks are hoarding. Yet the companies that mine, mill, and refine the very foundation of this demand are valued as though they’re relics of a bygone age. Albeit the VanEck Gold Miners ETF, known as the GDX, by far the largest gold miners exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the world has gained more than 90% year-to-date (as of September 3, 2025). But, this may be just a preview of the gains to come... According to Crescat Capital's The Countercyclicality of Gold Mining Stocks,

"Over the 11-year secular bull market for gold miners from 12/26/1969 to 10/17/1980, the Barron’s Gold Mining Index increased 1,247% while the S&P 500 was up only 43% over the same period."

In reality, gold miners are the pulse beneath the vault, the hands that keep the gleam alive. Their production is slowing, their costs are rising, albeit far slower than the price of gold in 2025, but they remain underowned with their recognition muted. And yet, the paradox of gold remains: in the shadow of the vault, the miners may hold alpha. Sometimes the market’s whispers carry the most meaning.